relationship_id,subject_entity_id,relationship_type,object_entity_id,confidence,rationale,source_id,review_status,period_id 3041,ENT_ISL_HASAN,child_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,"Hasan, the 2nd Imam, is the son of Ali.",SRC_MUFID_IRSHAD,reviewed, 3052,ENT_ISL_FATIMA,consort_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,Fatima is the wife of Ali.,SRC_MUFID_IRSHAD,reviewed, 5265,ENT_ISL_ABU_TALIB,parent_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,Abu Talib was the father of Ali ibn Abi Talib.,SRC_IBN_ISHAQ_SIRA,reviewed, 5267,ENT_ISL_JAFAR,sibling_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,"Ja'far and Ali were brothers, both sons of Abu Talib.",SRC_IBN_ISHAQ_SIRA,reviewed, 6561,ENT_YRS_SHAH_KHOSHIN,reception_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,"In the Yarsan chain of manifestations the theophany passes Khawandagar -> Ali -> Shah Khoshin; Shah Khoshin re-manifests the Essence borne by Ali (Hamzeh'ee, Mir-Hosseini). Object ENT_ISL_ALI verified existing.",SRC_HAMZEHEE_YARESAN,reviewed, 6589,ENT_ALW_ALI,reception_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,"The Alawite deified Ali (Ma'na) is a sectarian reception of the same historical Ali ibn Abi Talib venerated in mainstream/Twelver Shi'ism as first Imam (homonym, same person, divergent theology; Friedman 2010).",SRC_FRIEDMAN_NUSAYRI,reviewed, 6949,ENT_ALV_KIRKLAR,presided_over_by,ENT_ISL_ALI,medium,"In Alevi-Bektashi lore the assembly of the Forty is presided over by Ali (existing ENT_ISL_ALI), the central holy figure of the tradition.",SRC_BIRGE_BEKTASHI,reviewed, 6950,ENT_ALV_TRINITY,reception_of,ENT_ISL_ALI,high,The Alevi Hak-Muhammad-Ali triad receives Ali ibn Abi Talib (existing) as the locus of divine manifestation.,SRC_DRESSLER_WRITING,reviewed,